See and hear Bella Sound and YG Acoustics – a match made in heaven – at Capital Audiofest 2026, Nov. 13 – 15, at the beautiful Hilton Rockville in Rockville, MD, Room 315! Experience the Bella Sound difference and see for yourself what Unveiling the Music is all about!

Understanding Amplifier Specs – Part 2

We opened Part 1 of this series with the observation that the power amplifier is an enormously important part of an audio playback system, and suggested that an understanding of the specifications available for this component was a worthy undertaking.  Those seasoned enough to heft the price of a good amplifier are often a little too seasoned in the back to want to heft the weight of these beastly creatures, making the home audition something to enter into only after doing as much “virtual” research as possible.  Granted, the specifications do not obviate the listening evaluation, but understanding the specs may help weed out a few non-contenders.  Yet, the single best reason to understand amplifier specs is what the endeavor teaches about the intricacies of amplifiers in general.  With the firm belief that more familiarity is better than less, we set forth to expand into the topic of amplifier distortion.  

Nonlinearity Distortion

Strictly speaking, there are two broad categories of distortion, that which is related to the input signal, and that which is not.  For example, some form of noise that the amplifier imparts, which is not strictly related to the signal, is in the latter category.  For this issue, we will be focusing on the first category, and this includes, most notably, harmonic distortion and intermodulation distortion, the forms of so called “nonlinearity” distortion.

An ideal amplifier is a linear processor which produces an output that is proportional to the input, regardless of the magnitude of the input signal.  Consider an amplifier that produces an output voltage that is exactly twice that which is presented to the input.  1 volt in results in 2 volts out; 2 volts in results in 4 volts out, etc.  There are subtleties beyond this simple example, but for our basic purposes we would call this a perfectly linear amplifier, one whose nonlinearity distortion is exactly zero.  On the other hand, consider a case where 1 volt in results in 2 volts out, but 2 volts in results in 3.9 volts out.  This is a nonlinear behavior, one that will generate harmonic and intermodulation distortion.  What exactly are these two forms of distortion?

To understand harmonic distortion, we must move our point of view to the frequency domain.  Now, consider an input signal consisting of a single frequency, say 1 KHz (1 kilohertz, or 1000 Hertz, or 1000 cycles per second).  This is a single pitch or tone, very close to the center and peak sensitivity of the human hearing range.  A perfectly linear amplifier would output a signal containing only the one tone at its input, 1 KHz.  If there is any nonlinearity present, the output signal will contain additional tones at new frequencies, more specifically, 2 KHz, 3 KHz, 4 KHz, etc.  These new tones are called “harmonics” – they are not part of the original recording!  Depending on their strength, these harmonics may not be very noticeable, or they may call considerable attention to themselves.  When not under good control, harmonic distortion can sound harsh, brittle, garbled or congested. 

Without trying to define a specific boundary of acceptability, for this is quite subjective and dependent on the quality of the rest of the system, we will suffice it to say that the lower the amplitude of harmonics, the better.  Even if the harmonics are so low that they are not consciously recognized, the effect on listening enjoyment can be considerable.  The difference between a good system and a great one is largely a function of what micro-details are captured.  In the effort to present these micro-details, the presence of harmonic distortion represents a background mask through which the priceless details must make themselves heard.  A similar argument can be made about its companion, intermodulation distortion.  Defined as the distortion products traceable to two or more separate frequencies at the input, intermodulation distortion has a similar, and arguably greater masking effect than harmonic distortion.  Intermodulation distortion is rarely specified, but it tends to go hand-in-hand with harmonic distortion, so that an amplifier that is very clean harmonically tends to be very clean intermodulationally as well.

Harmonic distortion is usually specified as Total Harmonic Distortion, or THD, and is defined as the percent of equivalent voltage of all the harmonic energy to the equivalent voltage of the desired signal, with numbers ranging from 0.001% to 5% or more in some cases.  

Unfortunately, there are numerous subtleties regarding this subject that make comparison shopping more problematic than it might at first appear to be.  Let us take a look at a few of these subtleties:

Subtlety 1 – Conditions

THD is not a universal number for a given amplifier, it depends on power level, frequency of the test signal, and speaker load resistance.  In the best of cases, manufacturers will give at least one or more of these conditions when specifying THD.  Alternatively, they may give a range of conditions over which a specified value of THD will be met.  For instance, you may see stated that THD is 0.05%, 10-200W into 4 Ohms at 1 KHz.  This much reference information is, however, unusual.  Very often the distortion is specified without any reference conditions stated.  It is something to keep in mind.

Subtlety 2 – All Harmonics Do Not Sound the Same

In the minds and ears of many, not all harmonics are equal.  For instance, the second harmonic (2 KHz in our earlier example) is thought by some to be a pleasing source of smoothness, sweetness and musicality.  This harmonic is in rich supply in the Single Ended Triode (SET) tube amplifiers, and is largely responsible for the long-standing, cult-like following they have enjoyed.  But not all listeners are in this camp.  As mentioned, distortion is masking, and whatever “benefit” may be attributed to it, it comes at a price of hearing less deeply into the recording than would be possible without it getting in the way.  The odd harmonics do not enjoy such contested favor.  They are generally thought to be harsh and non-musical, and progressively worse, the higher the order.  A little 3rd and 5th harmonic may be tolerable, but orders beyond that are decidedly dissonant and harshly argumentative with the music.  The so called “balanced amplifier” architectures, no particular company is represented or implied, has found disfavor among the second harmonic or even-order harmonic enthusiasts, because of the even-order cancelling nature of balanced circuits – no sugar here!  To be fair to this subject, fondness for 2nd harmonic distortion is often found in the context of substantial 3rd order distortion.  Whereas odd order distortion is decidedly non-musical, an ample dose of even order distortion can be salve to the wound, yet all orders of distortion are masking to the original recording.  If the magic is in the subtleties, and it surely is, an amplifier may be more musical, and at the same time, less magical.  The deepest listening experience into the recording will almost assuredly be had where all forms of distortion are insignificantly small, and these experiences are often referred to as magical.  I realize that the foregoing statements are controversial and will not be accepted by everyone, particularly the SET people.  My aim is not to cast any judgement, but simply to observe that any contribution made by the amplifier that is not present in the original recording competes for the listener’s attention.

Subtlety 3 – Harmonic Descent

Another subtlety of this subject is found in the harmonic ensemble descent.  If there is harmonic distortion, and there always is, it comes in the form of frequencies harmonically related to the input tone (single tone for example clarity).  In our earlier example, a 1 KHz tone results in an infinite ensemble of harmonics: 2 KHz, 3 KHz, 4 KHz…, and the power level of these harmonics is generally falling off as order increases.  But how aggressively does the power level fall off?  On this point, not all amplifiers are equal.  For instance, you may have two amplifiers rated with the exact same THD, but amplifier 1 has a very rapid power descent of harmonics, whereas amplifier 2 has a very gradual descent.  The amount of 2nd order distortion (2 KHz) may be the same for the two cases, but the power level of the 9th order (9 KHz) may be very different.  Since 9th order harmonic distortion is decidedly egregious to the listener, the amplifiers sound very different – one would be purchased while the other would be passed on.  From this it can be seen that the path is divided along the lines of listener preference.  If you want a smooth and luxurious sound, the acoustical equivalent to a Louis XIII cognac after a hard day at the office, you may like SET tube amplifiers.  They are known for fairly high levels of THD, but largely comprised of the 2nd harmonic, with higher order terms falling off aggressively.  These can be beautiful sounding, a delight to the ears.  If, on the other hand, you want to hear every nuance that accompanied the original performance, as though you were there when it happened, all the size and spatial nuances, etc., you probably want to keep all nonlinearity distortion to an absolute minimum, including the 2nd harmonic.  To this, a corollary point can be made.  Harmonic descent is rarely specified or shown, but in such cases as the THD is very, very low, the descent is less important because everything is very low anyway.  

Subtlety 4 – Distortion Dependance on Power

One word of caution belongs to any discussion of this subject.  Distortion is usually dependent on the amount of power the amplifier is producing.  Depending on the architecture, an amplifier very commonly produces its worst TDH percentage at its maximum power level.  However, in the case of the Class A-B amplifier configurations, as opposed to Class A, there is usually an increase in THD percentage at very low power levels as well.  One would like a curve of THD verses power so he could see all this for himself, but it is almost never available and seldom fully measured by the manufacturer.  During listening sessions, try to determine if the clarity of playback is strongly dependent on the volume control setting.  Amplifiers that become congested at high listening levels will show their true colors under these conditions.  Beware that the speakers may also become over-driven at high levels, and so this type of examination requires speakers that are good for the volume levels you are reaching.  Amplifiers that become less clear, or lose the magic at low volume levels, may be suffering from a type of distortion found in Class A-B configurations known as crossover distortion.  This is easy to spot by turning the volume down and listening to see if the sound loses the magic at some low volume level.  Amplifiers that force the listener to crank up on it all the time are probably afflicted with excessive crossover distortion.  This subject is precisely the reason for the success of Class A amplifiers.  Known for their hefty size and power wasting appetites, they are devoid of crossover problems and maintain a beautiful clarity at any listening level.  There are many clever design subtleties that have reached the market, and there are certainly Class A-B designs that do not exhibit audible crossover distortion.  The Class A variety should be considered as a possibility, but it has been particularly well received by those who aren’t frugal with the power utility and who appreciate the side benefit of heating the room on a cold winter evening as well.

Subtlety 5 – Dynamic Distortion

A less well understood aspect of distortion also deserves mention, and that pertains to the subject of dynamic distortion.  Dynamic distortion is an additional distortion contribution that occurs only in the presence of a rapidly changing input signal level, for instance, a sudden crescendo at the end of a symphony.  Whereas THD is measured with a constant input signal level, the dynamic distortion contribution of an amplifier is completely absent from this measurement.  You are not likely to encounter any statement by the manufacturer on this topic, and so your ears will have to be the measuring instrument.  Listen for changes in clarity in the presence of sudden musical dynamics.  We are not talking about loudness levels, per se.  The effect of loudness level on distortion can be determined with the volume control.  The effect of dynamics on distortion must be ascertained using a recording in which explosive dynamics are present.  If dynamic distortion is strongly present, you will hear congestion and loss of clarity during the dynamic, without regard for the volume control setting.  One word of sincere caution is in order.  Powerful dynamics often challenge the recording equipment, resulting in loss of clarity and the introduction of congestion in the recording itself.  In view of this, a better test recording for dynamic distortion is one that contains less stressful dynamics, for instance, a crisp snare drum in a jazz quartet, where the dynamics of the snare are strongly present, but the peak volume level of the recording is not like what you would find in a huge symphony orchestra at crescendo.  I know, I am nitpicking. The point is to find a recording in which the dynamics are sudden, but the amplitude is below the point of saturating the recording and mastering equipment.  A good way to identify this recording is with a good pair of headphones and a good headphone amplifier.

From this discussion, you may be thinking that harmonic distortion specifications are not really very enabling, as the subject extends to much deeper levels than a single number could represent.  If that is your conclusion, congratulations – you have made an excellent case for listening to amplifiers and not just reading about them.  That said, the better the spec is, the more meaningful it is as well.  A really great THD spec, say 0.01% or better, bodes good things for the listener, whereas a number like 1% is going to be masking.  Tube amps are often around this number or higher, but in their defense, they usually have good harmonic descent, and the SET variety have 2nd order dominance that is music to some ears.  Solid state amplifiers need to be around 0.01% or better, because they do not have the redeeming presence of 2nd order dominance – they are best considered by listeners who want to hear every detail and nuance, as deeply as can be heard short of an out-of-body experience.  

None of the generalities made herein are going to apply well to every amplifier offering.  Many other considerations can spoil the magic, leaving the ears the honor of making the final call.  And so it is that amplifier specifications are more useful for culling out the least likely candidates than for affirming the inner circle ones.  Perhaps, to that extent, they sit side by side with price.  But if a clearer understanding can eliminate one painful audition, a clearer listening experience may be one step closer for those who educate themselves to an introductory level.

The topic of amplifier specifications will be continued in the next issue of The Audiophile Edge.


The information contained herein is presented in good faith and with all hopes of helping the reader to find the best equipment for an audio system.  Neither the author, nor Bella Sound LLC, assume any responsibility or liability due to loss on the part of the reader, owing to or believed to be owing to the content of this article, or resulting from or believed to be resulting from an application of the information contained herein, regardless the level of expertise engaged thereto. 

Mike Vice

President

Bella Sound

Photo of Mike Vice

On a lifelong pursuit of audio excellence.

Let’s connect

Get The Edge

Stay updated with our news and blog posts by joining our newsletter list.

We don’t spam! By subscribing you agree to receive our promotional materials. You may unsubscribe at any time. Read our policies for more info.

Never stop short of achieving your dreams.

Mike Vice